Adding an Element to a Scene

I've been painting many Hudson River scenes over the last few years and I often find myself having to decide whether to add boats or a barge or ship to complete the composition. It's sometimes a very clear choice--the scene needs a boat. Other times, it's a matter of adding that human element because the scene feels a little too static without it, or my eye keeps looking toward the open water and waiting for something to appear.
For this painting, "Motorboat Heading Toward Nyack", I hadn't included any foreground land and felt I wanted something active leading the eye to the far shore.
In each case, I look through a large selection of reference photos I've amassed while spending many hours along the River. The Hudson, being a major North/South artery, has quite a lot of traffic on it. Much of it in good weather is for pleasure, so I see all kinds of yachts, sight-seeing boats, sailboats, and kayaks and sometimes jet skies and windsurfers. But in addition, there are many large freighters and barges and tugboats in evidence.
It's a carefully thought out selection I make as to what to add and where to place it. I'll often make a little sketch to size and move it around over the painting to help me decide. Sometimes, after I've added an element, it doesn't feel right and I wipe it out. Sometimes, it feels like just the right touch. Several times before making my decision, I've asked my son and daughter what's their opinion and usually have one say add a boat and the other say don't. That leads me to think that it's often a totally arbitrary decision about whether it's needed or not to complete the scene.